EU: Court rules in favour of Marks and Spencer on tax
UK food and clothing retailer Marks and Spencer can claim back GBP30m (US$53m) in tax from the British government following a European Court of Justice ruling today (25 October).
Marks and Spencer claimed tax relief from the UK authorities following the closure of its Belgian, French and German subsidiaries. When the claim was refused Marks and Spencer brought proceedings against the government and the UK court asked the European Court of Justice to rule on whether the UK provisions were compatible with the EU rules on freedom of establishment.
The court ruled that the provisions do constitute a restriction on freedom of establishment. "In effect, the United Kingdom rules apply different treatment for tax purposes to losses incurred by a resident subsidiary and losses incurred by a non-resident subsidiary," the court said. "They therefore discourage undertakings from setting up subsidiaries in other member states."
"Such a restriction is permissible only where it pursues a legitimate objective compatible with the treaty and is justified by overriding reasons in the public interest," the court said. "It is further necessary, in such a situation, that the restriction be apt to ensure the attainment of the objective in question and that it does not go beyond what is necessary to attain that objective."
The justification given for the rule was that it was needed to avoid the double use of losses, and the risk of tax avoidance, with losses transferred to the member states with the highest rate of tax. The court felt these reasons were legitimate, but it felt that the UK rule went beyond what was necessary.
We're pleased that the decision has been made, but it's clearly not a very straightforward one and we're taking time to assess it before we comment any further," Marks and Spencer spokeswoman Clair Foster told just-food.
"The court has ruled that the UK tax regime isn't quite right, but overall, EU governments will be quite pleased with this result," Bill Dodwell, a tax partner at consultants Deloitte, told the BBC. "UK law went too far because it didn't allow M&S to claim tax relief in the UK, even when it couldn't claim it overseas because it had closed its operations."
Companies: Marks and Spencer
Milk sales are up - and although some people have put it down to increased consumption of porridge, tea and coffee, the milk industry is keen to capitalise on its newfound popularity. One way it is do...
We produce far too much non-biodegradable packaging waste, say the environmentalists. We're short of landfill sites and it's damaging the environment. Yet, one potential solution, biodegradable or com...
These days, to be successful, supermarkets must provide value and quality, low prices and convenience, as well as reliability, consistency and responsibility. Aiming for such high standards means a ch...
UK food and clothing retailer Marks and Spencer has said it expects group profit before tax and exceptionals for the 26 weeks to 1 October to be at or around the upper end of market expectations....
UK food and clothing retailer Marks and Spencer has hired a New York business guru to motivate its entire staff of 56,000 in a bid to boost the company's sales....
Food and clothing retailer Marks and Spencer has announced Marks and Spencer Group plc has today (Monday) announced the resignation of Charles Wilson, executive director for IT, logistics and property...
Food and clothing retailer Marks and Spencer has announced a 3.1% fall in its UK retail sales in its first quarter, the 14 weeks to 9 July 2005, but food sales were up by 5.0%....
UK food and clothing retailer Marks and Spencer may open its first store in Russia this year, according to the RIA Novosti news agency....
- US food next wave on display at Winter Fancy Food
- How General Mills plans to grow - CAGNY
- Comment: Meal kits in US - don't believe the hype
- CAGNY analysis: Danone's growth strategy
- Wessanen eyes growth in "resurgent" organic market
- Unilever launches operational review
- Glanbia focuses on nutrition with Irish dairy spin
- Bonduelle to buy US produce group Ready Pac Foods
- Mondelez launches savoury snacks brand Vea
- Maple Leaf buys US plant-based group Lightlife