US: Sugar firms file fresh action over HFCS marketing
A coalition of US sugar processors and refiners have filed fresh legal action against member companies of the Corn Refiners Association (CRA) over "deceptive marketing" of high fructose corn syrup (HFCS).
United States Sugar Corp, Western Sugar Cooperative, Michigan Sugar Co, and seven other companies are suing US agribusiness giants Archer Daniels Midland and Cargill, CRA announced yesterday (23 November). The amended complaint alleges that senior executives of the agribusiness conglomerates "organize[d] collectively in order to dominate and ... control" an ongoing marketing campaign to rename HFCS as "corn sugar".
The disagreement between the two industries dates back four years when the CRA re-branded HFSC as "corn sugar" and launched an advertising campaign. In September last year, the association petitioned the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for an official name change.
However, in April, the sugar industry filed a lawsuit charging the corn refining companies with "false advertising". The FDA has asked the corn sugar marketers to refrain from using the term until it considers the request but their advertising campaign has continued.
The fresh legal action argues that the ad campaign claims HFCS is a "natural" product equivalent to real sugar from cane and beet plants. The sugar farmers however, believe the claims are untrue and are seeking a court order to halt the adverts and financial damages.
"This litigation is about false advertising funded by CRA's biggest members," said Adam Fox, attorney for sugar growers at law firm Squire Sanders. "Sugar cane and beet farmers want the defendants to stop their false and misleading statements that harm consumers, harm the makers of real sugar and harm any dialogue based on the truth. This lawsuit seeks to put an end to the intentional deception."
However, Audrae Erickson, president of the CRA, said the sugar industry was "attempting to use the courts to stifle free speech" but "lacks the facts to support its claims".
"We believe that the sugar industry's views are misleading American consumers," Erickson said. "The CRA will continue its work to educate consumers about high fructose corn syrup and will vigorously oppose the sugar industry's attempt to stifle public discussion of this important health issue."
A number of major suppliers have built a significant presence in the stevia sector, with new entrants emerging. Jonathan Thomas looks at the major players in the industry - Cargill and PureCircle - an...
Dairy giant Arla Foods grabbed the headlines this week with the admission 250 jobs could go at the company, with the possibility of more to come, as it looks to drive efficiency. Elsewhere, Kellogg an...
US sugar refiner Imperial Sugar, which earlier this month agreed to a takeover bid from Louis Dreyfus Commodities, has reported higher half-year losses....
The US Food & Drug Administration (FDA) has unveiled a four-year plan that aims to meet seven goals by 2016 and details 100 initiatives related to food safety, nutrition and animal health....
Archer Daniels Midland's (ADM) third-quarter earnings dropped 31% on the back of lower ethanol prices and weak European oilseed results, the company said today (1 May)....
US agribusiness giant Cargill has completed a US$82m upgrade to a cocoa processing facility in the Netherlands....
- M&A Watch: Raisio should sell to private equity
- Analysis: Market bets on higher Chiquita offer
- On the money: Solid Lindt outpaces chocolate peers
- Briefing: Expansion agenda of Japan's food majors
- Why exporters still see opportunities in Japan
- Kerry cools claim spreads move could hit jobs
- Pork Farms buys Kerry Group's pastry plants
- Campbell Soup's Plum division to pull out of UK
- Profits up at chocolate group Lindt
- Japan's Sanyo takes stake in Olam's food biz