Blog: Muddy waters on obesity
Catherine Sleep | 28 January 2004
The public obesity debate last night proved to be one of those irritating evenings where absolutely everyone comes out with exactly the argument you could have predicted they would, and no consensus is reached beyond platitudes such as “we must all work together,” “yes, child health is important” and “more information is a good thing”.
Most participants agreed that the problem underlying the so-called “obesity epidemic” we face was not universal ignorance of which foods are healthy and which are not, but widespread difficulty in making the right choices. Fresh-faced, eloquent but understandably naïve “youth activist” Kierra Box, 18, suggested rebranding the lower fat/sugar/salt versions of processed foods as the “conventional” product, while slapping a label on the hitherto conventional variety indicating that it should henceforth be considered the “Gonna make you fat” variety. Ah, bless.
Nutrition Scientist Dr Susan Jebbs was all for bold action, as currently the diet of the nation’s children is so far away from healthy that it is essential that drastic measures are undertaken right now. 85% of kids eat more than the recommended daily intake of sugar, she pointed out.
Whether this action should take the form of banning the endorsement of foods of minimal nutritional benefit by sport celebrities, banning the inclusion of toys in food products, or a snack tax, or the introduction of an advertising watershed, or clearer labelling, or a combination of the above, will be a matter of intense debate over coming months and years.
Richard D. North, media fellow at the Institute of Economic Affairs, was against any kind of government intervention, arguing that obesity is parents’ and kids’ fault, they should accept it, take responsibility for their own diets and stop passing the buck. Any kind of “Nanny State” intervention would be to infantilise people. Not sure I agree with that – it irks me when people brand any sensible suggestion for helping and educating people as something only a Nanny State would do.
And if I had a pound for every time I heard that old chestnut about there being “no such thing as unhealthy food, just unhealthy diets” one more time, I’d be a rich woman.
The debate highlighted public ignorance of how advertising works, a useful reminder for both government and industry. Several members of the public questioned why the advertising industry didn't use its proven expertise at flogging stuff to improve the reputation and penetration of healthier products, such as fruit and veg? Um, because advertising agencies work for clients who pay them. Obvious to me, and to you no doubt too, but not, evidently, to everyone.
The most succinct contributions came from the floor, not the podium. Kath Dalmeny of the Food Commission argued that, whichever way you look at it, a yoghurt pot marketed at toddlers that contains 80% of a child’s recommended daily sugar intake is plain wrong. Few would argue with that.
We hear a lot in the food industry about two interconnected trends: and social media and “foodie” culture....
Nestle, set to welcome a new CEO on 1 January, has announced more changes to the make-up of its senior management team....
Blue Bell Creameries is trying to win back the trust of consumers after a fatal listeriosis outbreak last year was linked to its products - but in recent days the US ice cream maker has issued another...
The UK's competition regulator has given the all-clear to Hain Celestial's bid to buy UK food and beverage group Orchard House Foods, nine months after the US group announced the deal....
- General Mills on Q1, innovation, margins
- Interview: Mondelez's outlook for China
- Interview: Mondelez eyes sweet success in China
- What next for Bernard Matthews? - comment
- How food companies involve staff in sustainability
- Aryzta FY profits fall
- ConAgra acquires Frontera Foods' "gourmet" brands
- Nestle close to finalising Garoto deal
- Nestle revamps foodservice arm
- Ireland unveils national plan to tackle obesity
- The Big 15: Strategies and Priorities of Top Packaged Food Players in Comparison
- Global Chocolate Confectionery Overview: Challenges, Opportunities and Risks
- Global Foodservice Market 2016-2020
- Constellation Brands, Inc. (STZ) - Financial and Strategic SWOT Analysis Review
- Fast Food Restaurants in the US - Industry Market Research Report