Blog: Tyson Foods investors left to chew over analyst claims
Dean Best | 10 October 2016
Shares in Tyson Foods slumped on Friday, closing down almost 9% after an analyst claimed a lawsuit facing the company could hit the US meat titan.
Tyson Foods was among more than a dozen poultry processors to be named in a suit filed last month by New York-based distributor Maplevale Farms, which claimed the businesses "conspired and combined to fix, raise, maintain, and stabilise the price of broilers" from as early as January 2008.
A second, class-action suit then emerged echoing the allegations.
Contacted by just-food last month, Tyson said: "We dispute the claims made in these complaints and will defend ourselves in court."
Tim Ramey, an analyst at Pivotal Research Group, issued a note to clients last week in which he insisted he was not alleging Tyson had colluded on pricing or production - but did say the suit was "powerfully convincing".
"Our thesis is that the class-action suit has merit and will lead to intense scrutiny of the broiler sector," Ramey wrote, according to Reuters. "We have long wondered how an industry marked by such volatility and lack of discipline could morph to a highly disciplined industry where production remains constrained and pricing remains high."
The note - and subsequent tumble in Tyson's share price - prompted the company to make the unusual move of issuing a statement.
"An analyst report has been issued this morning commenting on pending antitrust litigation which was filed over a month ago. While we don’t normally make substantive comments regarding pending litigation, we dispute the allegations in the complaints as well as the speculative conclusions reached by the analyst, and we will defend ourselves in court. Contrary to what the analyst assumed, we have not made any changes to our business practices in response to the complaints," Tyson said.
The ball, clearly, is in the hands of the US courts. One would imagine Ramey was confident enough in his assertions to have published the note but, equally, Tyson must be sure in its position to have responded swiftly. One to watch.
Since Theresa May took over as UK Prime Minister in the wake of the country's referendum vote to quit the European Union, she and her ministers have been at pains not to divulge their negotiating posi...
Greenpeace's long-running campaign against UK tuna brand John West, owned by seafood giant Thai Union, is now directing its fire against Sainsbury's....
The Obama administration appears to have conceded the landmark Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) trade deal will not be pushed through in the lame-duck session of Congress before Donald Trump is inaugur...
- Unilever 2016 investor day - the top takeaways
- The key questions for digital strategists in 2017
- Have food promotions reached tipping point?
- How Tyson's new CEO plans to grow the meat group
- Mondelez goes beyond certified cocoa - analysis
- Nestle unveils process to cut sugar by 40%
- Unilever sets new margin target with help from ZBB
- Unilever focuses on "value" of spreads arm
- Japan's Nagatanien buys Chaucer Food Group
- Wilmar urges palm oil "labour transformation"