Three men were unfairly jailed for their part in a pet-food-for-human-consumption racket between 1993-1996, according to their defence lawyers.

Discover B2B Marketing That Performs

Combine business intelligence and editorial excellence to reach engaged professionals across 36 leading media platforms.

Find out more


The nationwide scam that involved five men, Nottinghamshire-based Andrew Boid and Darren Bibby, Peter Tantram of Ingham and Arnold Smith and John McGinty from South Yorkshire, selling condemned poultry meat for human consumption attracted widespread attention when it first went to court in September last year.


Due to evidence thrown up by an investigation by Rotherham environmental health officials and South Yorkshire police, the men were found guilty of heavily disguising condemned meat between 1993 and 1996 and selling in on to unknowing butchers, restaurants and retailers across the UK.


The lawyers have now taken the case to the Court of Appeal, maintaining that the trial was unfair because the jury was clouded in “confusion and bewilderment” while deliberating. The lawyers also argue that Judge Heppel, presiding over the case, entered into “forbidden territory.” In a bid to save the four-month trial from collapse, they argue that he unfairly inquired into the jurors’ problems and sent them back to resume deliberation on some charges on which they had already returned verdicts.


To read about the case in court, click here.

GlobalData Strategic Intelligence

US Tariffs are shifting - will you react or anticipate?

Don’t let policy changes catch you off guard. Stay proactive with real-time data and expert analysis.

By GlobalData

To read about the poultry scam in the UK, click here.


To find out about the benefits of full membership of just-food.com, please click here.

Just Food Excellence Awards - Nominations Closed

Nominations are now closed for the Just Food Excellence Awards. A big thanks to all the organisations that entered – your response has been outstanding, showcasing exceptional innovation, leadership, and impact.

Excellence in Action
Winning five categories in the 2025 Just Food Excellence Awards, Centric Software is setting the pace for digital transformation in food and FMCG. Explore how its integrated PLM and PXM suite delivers faster launches, smarter compliance and data-driven growth for complex, multi-channel product portfolios.

Discover the Impact