US spice maker Watkins Inc has added black peppercorn grinders to its lawsuit against McCormick & Co that alleges the flavours giant "slack fills" its pepper tins.

According to Watkins, McCormick has reduced the contents of its tins by 25% and grinders by approximately 20%, in violation of federal "slack fill" prohibitions. The company initially filed a lawsuit against McCormick at the beginning of this month. Watkins claims McCormick is attempting to "deceive and confuse retailers and their customers" by trying to make the tins and grinders look like they contain more than they do.

Discover B2B Marketing That Performs

Combine business intelligence and editorial excellence to reach engaged professionals across 36 leading media platforms.

Find out more

Watkins' CEO Mark Jacobs said: "If McCormick is permitted to blatantly violate the slack fill regulations which are designed to protect the consumer and keep the competitive marketplace fair, what's next?…selling an 8 ounce container with 1 ounce in it and then telling the consumers they should read the labels more carefully?"

McCormick has said it believes the suit is not justified and insisted that it will defend itself "vigorously."

Just Food Excellence Awards - Nominations Closed

Nominations are now closed for the Just Food Excellence Awards. A big thanks to all the organisations that entered – your response has been outstanding, showcasing exceptional innovation, leadership, and impact.

Excellence in Action
Winning five categories in the 2025 Just Food Excellence Awards, Centric Software is setting the pace for digital transformation in food and FMCG. Explore how its integrated PLM and PXM suite delivers faster launches, smarter compliance and data-driven growth for complex, multi-channel product portfolios.

Discover the Impact