The good news for McDonald’s is that people are responsible for their own waistlines and cannot blame fastfood companies for being overweight. So says a US judge in a headline grabbing court case. McDonald’s will be pleased to avoid a potential avalanche of copycat cases. It will be less happy to find itself back in the glare of the media spotlight.
Falling sales in the US and Europe and charges of US$656.9m to cover the cost of closures, restructuring and job losses have pushed McDonald’s to a Q4 loss of $344m, its first ever loss.
Only days earlier, McDonald’s was let off the legal hook with the dismissal of the first ‘obesity’ suit against it, which could have opened the flood gates to a host of similar suits.
McDonald’s was accused of negligence in not making clear the potential health risks of a diet overly reliant on fast food. But the judge ruled that consumers could not blame McDonald’s for their excessive consumption of its burgers.
Public opinion has tended to side against the plaintiffs. Ordinary Americans have found it hard to stomach the suggestion that anyone could have missed the avalanche of publicity over the health dangers of fastfood. But ironically it is precisely the growing concern over fastfood and health that is at least partly behind McDonald’s falling sales.
In other areas too, McDonald’s fortunes have changed. The company has responded actively to criticism of its environmental record, but still produces over a million tons of packaging annually. Once a flagship for the American dream, the opening of a McDonald’s in Moscow or Beijing could guarantee international publicity. More recently, the anti-capitalist backlash and contentious US foreign policies have made it a target for anti-American sentiment.
Although public opinion favoured McDonald’s in the obesity case, these are issues that for some consumers have tarnished its all-American image.
McDonald’s has escaped its recent day in court financially and legally intact. But by keeping fastfood in the headlines, the case may very well prompt many previously loyal consumers to examine their own diets and to seek out more healthy alternatives. As the company dips into the red, it’s the kind of publicity it can do without.
(c) 2003 Datamonitor. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without prior written consent. Datamonitor shall not be liable for errors or delays in the content, or for any actions taken in reliance thereon.